How to evaluate AI agents before they reach production
An agent that passes a demo can still fail in a hundred quiet ways. Evals and regression gates turn 'it seems fine' into evidence.
Traditional software has unit tests. Language models are probabilistic, so many teams decide testing doesn't apply and ship on vibes. That's a mistake. Agents need more testing, not less. It just looks different.
What to measure
Judging an agent on its final answer alone misses most of the ways it can fail. Evaluate the whole trajectory:
- Task success: did it achieve the goal?
- Tool use: did it call the right tools, with the right arguments, in a sensible order?
- Efficiency: how many steps, tokens and how much money did it take?
- Safety: did it stay within policy, and did it escalate when it should have?
- Consistency: run the same case five times. Do you get the same outcome?
Build a golden set
Start with 30 to 50 real cases that represent your workload. Include:
- Typical, everyday requests
- Known edge cases and past failures
- Adversarial inputs, such as prompt injection and out-of-scope requests
- Cases where the right answer is to escalate to a human
For each case, record what "good" looks like. That might be an exact answer, required tool calls, or a rubric for a grader.
Grading: rules first, models second
Use deterministic checks wherever you can: schema matches, correct tool called, amount within range. Use a model as grader only for judgements that need it, such as tone or completeness. Spot-check the grader against human ratings, too.
Make evals a gate, not a report
The real value comes from wiring evals into your release process:
- Every prompt, model or tool change runs the full eval suite.
- Scores are compared against the current production baseline.
- If a regression passes a threshold, the change is blocked.
A model upgrade that improves average scores but breaks your three most important edge cases is not an upgrade.
Keep the set alive
Every production incident should become a new eval case. Over time your golden set becomes a record of everything your agent has ever got wrong, and a guarantee it won't get those things wrong again.
See Argos Nexus AI in action
Governed agents, human review and full audit — in one platform.